Which trade should I do? 10 points for best answer!?

I would do them both the first one would be a rip off for the guy u would be trading with and the second one is also good you get an average short stop for a short stop who is struggeling and a rookie pitcher for either Roy Halladay who leads the leuge in wins or Johan Santana who is always good. I would take Holladay because santana does not get run support so he would not get points for the win